Game 5 vs Stars 2019
Rinne's heroics not enough in controversial Game 5 loss.
Game 5 of the 2019 Western Conference Quarterfinals between the Nashville Predators and the Dallas Stars is remembered as one of the most dramatic and controversial matches in Predators playoff history. Played at Bridgestone Arena, this elimination game saw the Predators fight to stay alive against a desperate Stars team, culminating in a wild, high-scoring affair that ended in a heartbreaking 5-3 loss. The match is iconic not only for its intensity but for the legendary performance of Predators goaltender Pekka Rinne, who made a series of miraculous saves, and a controversial no-goal call that still sparks heated debate among fans and analysts alike.
- Series
- Western Conference Quarterfinals, Game 5
- Venue
- Bridgestone Arena, Nashville, TN
- Result
- Dallas Stars 5, Nashville Predators 3
- Series Outcome
- Stars win series 4-2
- Key Player
- Pekka Rinne (Predators) – 47 saves
- Notable Incident
- Controversial no-goal call on a potential Predators tally
Lore & Background
Game 5 of the 2019 series is etched in Predators lore as a microcosm of the team's never-say-die identity, even in defeat. The Predators entered the game trailing the series 3-1, facing elimination on home ice. From the opening faceoff, the atmosphere was electric, with fans roaring for a miracle. Pekka Rinne, the franchise's all-time winningest goaltender, delivered one of the most remarkable performances of his career, stopping 47 of 52 shots, including several jaw-dropping saves that kept the Predators within striking distance. The game featured a flurry of goals, with the Stars taking an early lead, the Predators battling back, and the lead changing hands multiple times. The defining moment came late in the third period when a Predators shot appeared to cross the goal line, but the officials ruled no goal after review, sparking outrage and disbelief among players, coaches, and the sellout crowd. The Stars capitalized shortly after, sealing the victory and the series. Despite the loss, the game is remembered as a testament to the Predators' resilience and the emotional bond between the team and its fans.
In Their Own Story
The air in Bridgestone Arena was thick with desperation and hope. Down 3-1 in the series, the Predators knew this could be their last stand. From the first drop of the puck, the game was a blur of speed and violence. Pekka Rinne stood tall in his crease, a fortress under siege. He robbed Jamie Benn with a glove save that defied physics, then stacked his pads to deny Tyler Seguin. The crowd roared with every save, willing their team to life. The Predators fought back, trading goals with the Stars in a seesaw battle that left everyone breathless. With the score tied late in the third, a shot from the point trickled through a maze of bodies. The puck disappeared under Stars goaltender Ben Bishop. For a split second, the arena held its breath. Then the referee waved it off. No goal. The replay showed the puck might have crossed the line, but it was too late. The Stars scored moments later, and the dream died. As the final horn sounded, the fans stood and applauded, not for the victory, but for the fight—a testament to a team that refused to go quietly.
Reader's Guide
Game 5 of the 2019 Western Conference Quarterfinals was a do-or-die match for the Nashville Predators, who faced elimination on home ice against the Dallas Stars. The occasion was the fifth game of a best-of-seven series, with the Stars leading 3-1. For the Predators, a loss meant the end of their season; for the Stars, a win would clinch the series and advance them to the second round.
Did You Know?
- Pekka Rinne's 47 saves in Game 5 were the most by a Predators goaltender in a playoff game that season.
- The controversial no-goal call in the third period was reviewed by the NHL's Situation Room but upheld, leading to widespread debate among fans and analysts.
- This was the first playoff series between the Predators and Stars since the Stars relocated from Minnesota in 1993.
- The Predators were eliminated in the first round for the second consecutive year after reaching the Stanley Cup Final in 2017.
More in Iconic Matches
Elsewhere in the Nashville Predators universe
Spotted an error? Know more?
This is a living reference — every entry is fact-audited, and reader corrections feed straight into our audit queue. Suggest an edit · See this site's audit record
